90s toys that are worth a ton today

The glorious 90’s, where cartoons, toys, and even candy just seemed so much better than they do now!   These iconic toys from the 90s have now become collector’s items and worth much more than what they originally sold for.  If you’re lucky, you can still find them at garage sales and thrift stores.  Next time you do, snatch them up!

Bop It / Bop It Extreme

Bop ItBop It Extreme

Bop it was one of the most addictive games of the 1990’s. It had three major functions, and all you had to do was follow them in order. It was quite simple, you either had to twist it, pull it, or bop it. Simple right? 🙂  In new condition, the Bop It is going for $90 dollars.  The Bop It Extreme is going for $125 dollars.

Original Furby

The electronic talking half-alien, half-gremlin toy that every kid wanted.  The robotics were state-of-the-art back in the day.  Original first edition Furbys are now going for $90 dollars.

American Girl Dolls

If you were a girl (maybe boys too) growing up in the 90’s, you probably wanted American Girl dolls. They were absolutely beautiful and huge compared to all of the other dolls on the market.   American Girl Dolls’ two most popular discontinued dolls Felicity and Samantha are worth around $200 each.

Original Tamagotchi


Tamagotchi was the toy every kid wanted and it was so far ahead of its time.  You could own virtual pet right there on key-chained size device. Original Tamagotchis are valued between $50-200 dollars these days.

Super Soaker 50

The iconic air-powered water blaster was introduced in the 90s.  Summer months was changed forever after the introduction of the super soaker.  There were many different variants over the years but the original is now worth around $150 dollars.

Gold Gameboy

This gold version was made for a select few Nintendo Power magazine subscribers can now fetch upwards of $200.

Girl Talk Original Game

Remember this board game that ruled at all sleepovers?  An original Girl Talk board game in its unopened form is now worth over $130.  Even used games are worth at least $40 dollars.

Linux for PS2

Most people enjoyed playing games on their PS2 but a few wanted to run Linux instead.  Very few copies were made and Linux PS2 copies are worth a cool $100 if you can find them.

Easy Bake Oven

This ionic easy bake oven from the 90s allowed kids to bake their own cookies and cupcakes.  These now fetch at least $60 dollars if still new.

Other Flipping Income Posts

8 Things to Buy and Sell on Craigslist to Make Money Craigslist came out during the dot-com era of the 90s and has stayed true to its roots for over 20 years.  You can definitely tell by the ancient ...
How To Make Money With These 6 Items From Dollar Tree (Part 2) Welcome to the second installment of How To Make Money With These 6 Items From Dollar Tree!  For those that are new to the series, don't miss Part...
What to Buy at Garage Sales to Resell Do you get excited seeing a new garage sale sign being put up on your street corner?  Do you have an uncontrollable urge to pull over to every gar...
12 Cool & Weird Things Being Sold On Etsy For those of you who aren't familiar with Etsy, it's an online marketplace catering to people who love making unique homemade pieces.  Over 60 mil...
How To Resell Clothes From Outlet Malls I'm going to cover one of my secrets with flipping and that's to resell new clothes you get off the rack or shelf from outlet stores.  For most of...