Original Tickle Me Elmo
Who doesn’t love Elmo? The original Tickle Me Elmo doll from 1996 is now worth as much as $250.
I don’t know what a Furby is nor do I want to but an original first edition 1998 Furby can is now valued over $400.
American Girl Dolls
American Girl Dolls’ two most popular discontinued dolls Felicity and Samantha are worth around $300 each.
Original Tamagotchis are valued around $50 dollars these days.
Super Soaker 50
The iconic air-powered water blaster can be picked up around $80.
This gold version was made for a select few Nintendo Power magazine subscribers can now fetches upwards of $200.
Girl Talk Original Game
An original Girl Talk board game in its unopened form is now worth over $140.
Linux for PS2
Very few copies were made and Linux PS2 copies are worth a cool $100.
This is just a small sample of 90s toys that are worth a ton today! eBay is going to be your best friend in terms of selling these items for top dollar. Good luck and start looking for these items during your next garage sale and thrift store run.